What are some colleges like Bard and Vassar that are easier to get in?

Artsy liberal arts schools that are easier than Bard and Vassar - there are plenty! I'd have you look at Hampshire, Bennington, New College of Florida, and Reed - those are the first ones that jumped into my mind for you. Others you could look at, see if they are artsy enough, include Hobart & William Smith, Goucher College, St. Michael's College (in VT), Stonehill, Siena, Simmons, and Wells. I think those may not be artsy enough for you, but I admit I'm not 100% sure of that on all of them, so I suggest you check them out and make the judgment.